The Evolution from Traditional Foreign Trade to Cross-Border E-commerce

Posted on by

Cross-border e-commerce is a complex and competitive industry, often misrepresented by exaggerated claims of easy profits and minimal effort. While it offers significant opportunities, it is far from a “get rich quick” scheme, requiring professional knowledge, accumulated experience, and substantial resource investment.

To understand cross-border e-commerce, it’s crucial to examine its predecessor, traditional foreign trade:

  • Traditional Foreign Trade :
    • Golden Era (Early 2000s): This period allowed many to become wealthy due to information asymmetry and supply-demand imbalances. China’s low production costs (e.g., a T-shirt costing $2-3 to produce, selling for $15-20 abroad) offered large profit margins, typically 30% to 50%. For instance, small toys costing less than 5 RMB could sell for $7-8 in the US, yielding about 60 RMB profit per toy. Controlling foreign trade channels was akin to “controlling a money printing machine”.
    • Decline and Challenges: The golden era ended due to several factors:
      • Payment Term Risks: Customers often demanded payment after delivery, with terms ranging from 90 to 180 days, leading to high risk of non-payment if foreign customers faced bankruptcy. An example cited was an 800,000 RMB loss due to a US client’s bankruptcy in 2008.
      • Large Batch Requirements: Traditional foreign trade typically involved shipping goods by containers, necessitating tens of thousands of dollars in goods and high capital pressure.
      • Increased Competition: As more Chinese factories entered the market, price wars intensified, drastically compressing profit margins to 10-15% by 2010, aligning with the economic principle of profit regression to the mean.
      • Rising Manufacturing Costs: Labor costs (e.g., factory worker monthly wages in Guangdong rising from 700-800 RMB in 2000 to 6,000 RMB by 2015) and raw material costs increased, eroding China’s low-cost advantage.
  • Cross-Border E-commerce – Version 2.0 of Foreign Trade:
    • Core Principle: The fundamental difference lies in eliminating intermediaries and shifting from a B2B to a B2C model. This means selling products directly from the manufacturer/seller to the end consumer globally via the internet. This direct connection can significantly increase profits by cutting out wholesale and retail layers. For example, a Bluetooth earphone with a factory price of $15 might sell for $48 in traditional retail, but directly to the consumer via a platform like Amazon for $32, potentially doubling the seller’s profit while offering a better price to the consumer.
    • General Challenges: Despite the allure of higher profits, the widespread adoption of cross-border e-commerce models quickly leads to profit dilution due to intense competition. New issues emerge:
      • High Single-Item Logistics Costs: Unlike container shipping, individual parcel shipping is expensive (e.g., a 1kg package to the US costing 80-200 RMB), significantly eroding profits. This is the reverse of economies of scale.
      • Direct Customer Interaction: Sellers must handle customer service, after-sales, and marketing directly, facing thousands of ordinary consumers with varied and sometimes “quirky” demands, not just professional buyers. This requires dealing with emotional and cognitive biases, not just rational needs.
      • Complex and Volatile Platform Rules: Major e-commerce platforms have intricate and constantly changing rules and fee structures, requiring sellers to remain vigilant to avoid being “out of the game”.
      • Intensified Competition: The low entry barrier (e.g., simply using translation software) has led to global sellers competing on the same platforms. Categories that had a dozen sellers in 2013 now have thousands, including factory-direct stores, making it a “red ocean”. Without core competitiveness, new entrants often become “cannon fodder”. Survivor bias often masks the high failure rate, showing only the few successes.

Mainstream Cross-Border E-commerce Platforms

Each platform has distinct characteristics, advantages, and challenges:

  • Amazon:
    • Overview: The most dominant cross-border e-commerce platform, functioning as a “global super shopping mall” with over 300 million active users and 2.5 billion monthly visits. Its “flywheel” model (more sellers -> more product selection -> better user experience -> more customers -> more sellers) drives its success.
    • Advantages: Offers a mature ecosystem for sellers, encompassing logistics, payments, and returns, with high levels of automation. The Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) service is highly convenient for small teams, providing ready access to Amazon’s warehouses and shipping, and leveraging the high consumer trust in the Amazon brand.
    • Challenges/Costs: Amazon’s fee structure is described as “vampire-like,” extracting profits from every aspect.
      • High Fees: Monthly account fees start at $39.99. Platform commissions range from 15% to over 40% (e.g., 45% for health products), significantly cutting into revenue.
      • Rising Logistics Costs: International shipping, especially to Amazon’s US warehouses, requires 2-3 months planning and significant cost. During the pandemic, container shipping from China to the US surged from $3,000 to $20,000.
      • Advertising Expenses: Advertising is “astronomical,” with top search results often being ads. Without ad spend, visibility is minimal. CPC (cost-per-click) can be several dollars (e.g., $1.8/click for smart home products, leading to ~$20 in ad cost per order).
      • Mature Market Dynamics: Amazon is a “zero-sum game” , where new sellers must compete fiercely with established ones for traffic and orders. Large sellers with capital advantages can sustain themselves, while small sellers fall into a vicious cycle of high costs, low profits, and insufficient capital. A seller lost $20,000 trying to sell kitchenware on Amazon US in 2020, despite good product quality, due to slim margins and fierce competition.
      • Account Security Risk: A significant hidden danger is the risk of account suspension, which can lead to the overnight collapse of a business, as seen in the 2021 Amazon account ban wave for Chinese sellers. Inventory held in Amazon’s warehouses can be lost or extremely costly to retrieve if an account is banned.
      • Success Factors: Success on Amazon now hinges on understanding the platform’s operational mechanisms and having sufficient capital to manage high costs and risks, rather than just having a good product.
  • Independent Websites :
    • Overview: These are self-built e-commerce websites (e.g., using Shopify for $29/month) that are not reliant on third-party platforms. They are akin to building a store in the suburbs: low rent, but no guaranteed traffic – sellers must actively attract customers.
    • Advantages: Offer complete control over product, pricing, marketing, website design, and user experience. They are ideal for brand building and storytelling. Unlike Amazon, where customer data belongs to the platform, independent sites allow sellers to collect customer information (emails, phone numbers) to build CRM systems for targeted follow-up marketing. This leads to higher repurchase rates and lifetime customer value. With virtually no platform commissions (apart from ~3% ad/handling fees), profit margins can be significantly higher (e.g., 40% gross profit vs. 20% on Amazon). Traffic sources can also be diversified (e.g., Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest).
    • Challenges: The biggest hurdle is zero organic traffic initially. A new independent site without promotion is like an isolated island.
      • High Advertising Costs: Traffic acquisition is the primary initial cost, with advertising fees on platforms like Facebook and Google constantly rising (e.g., Facebook CPC increased from $0.2-0.3 to $0.8-1.2). A beauty product seller spent $120,000 on ads in three months, only earning $70,000 in revenue.
      • Difficulty Building Trust: New websites struggle to gain consumer trust, resulting in lower conversion rates (0.5% vs. 2-3% on Amazon).
      • High Technical Maintenance Costs: Requires professional knowledge or services for website optimization, security, payment systems, and logistics integration (e.g., $700-800/month for tech services).
      • Complex Logistics: Sellers are fully responsible for global logistics, including dealing with shipping issues (loss, delays, damage), complex customs regulations, and international tax rules (e.g., incurring high fees/fines due to unfamiliarity with Italian VAT rules).
      • High Entry Barrier: Independent sites have the highest technical and marketing thresholds in cross-border e-commerce. Product quality accounts for only 20% of success; the remaining 80% depends on comprehensive capabilities in marketing, technology, customer service, and logistics. Over 90% of new independent sites fail within a year, making them “dead sites” if not properly operated.
      • Recommendation: Newcomers in marketing should gain experience on third-party platforms like Amazon before venturing into independent sites.
  • TikTok Shop:
    • Overview: An e-commerce system built upon TikTok’s immense popularity, allowing users to directly purchase products seen in short videos. Its rapid growth is due to being in a “platform bonus period” .
    • Advantages: During its bonus period, it offers low-cost user acquisition. A seller friend earned $20,000 in three months with almost zero investment, primarily through content. Achieving similar sales on Facebook or Google would cost $5,000-8,000 in advertising. The “see and buy” content e-commerce model, highly successful in China, is highly effective internationally. It caters to a younger demographic (18-35 years old) and is well-suited for beauty, apparel, and small appliance categories.
    • Challenges/Risks:
      • High Platform Volatility: Policies and rules are frequently adjusted, making it less stable than traditional platforms like Amazon. Examples include sudden changes in seller entry requirements (e.g., requiring US companies and bank accounts), which left many unprepared, causing significant losses. This is a form of “policy risk”.
      • Demanding Content Quality: Success is highly dependent on creating engaging video content; simple product displays will not gain traffic. Sellers must be excellent content creators and essentially act as “influencers”.
      • Supply Chain Strain: Viral content can lead to sales surges (e.g., 5,000+ orders in three days), which can overwhelm unprepared supply chains, resulting in order cancellations, negative reviews, and account demotion.
      • High Logistics Efficiency Demand: TikTok Shop customers, often making impulse purchases, are less patient than Amazon customers, expecting faster delivery (complaints after 5 days, compared to 7-10 days on Amazon).
      • Regional Restrictions: Currently available only in limited countries, with global coverage far less than Amazon.
      • Recommendation: Due to its “bonus period” and rapid changes, those interested should act quickly.
  • Temu :
    • Overview: Positioned as a new benchmark for Chinese cross-border e-commerce, it thrives on “extreme cost-effectiveness coupled with algorithm-driven sales”. It offers unbelievably low prices in Western markets (e.g., $1.99 T-shirts, $5.99 dresses).
    • Business Model: Its core is the C2M (Consumer to Manufacturer) model, directly connecting consumers with manufacturers and eliminating all intermediate layers in the supply chain. It also employs Pinduoduo’s group-buying and bargaining features for viral user growth.
    • The “Trap” for Individual Sellers: Despite market promotions, the source explicitly states that it’s “almost impossible” for ordinary individual sellers to profit on Temu, and training courses promising easy entry or “no-inventory models” are “scams”.
    • Strict Supplier Entry Barriers: Temu sets extremely high requirements for suppliers:
      • Massive Annual Production Capacity: Often exceeding 1 million units.
      • Comprehensive Factory Qualifications: Including export licenses and various certifications.
      • Acceptance of Strict Standards and Extremely Low Profit Margins.
      • Ultra-Long Payment Terms: Ranging from 90 to 180 days.
    • Platform Nature: Temu is fundamentally a “super procurement platform operating as a B2B2C platform for factories,” not an open platform for individual sellers. Therefore, unless one is a factory or a large trading company, direct entry is highly unlikely.
  • Etsy (EASE):
    • Overview: A niche platform focusing on handmade goods, vintage items, and artistic creations, with ~96 million global users. Buyers on Etsy often seek to purchase “emotion and identity”.
    • Advantages: Targets a niche, creative market with less direct price competition. Products are typically unique. Buyers are willing to pay a premium for uniqueness, such as handmade or customized items (e.g., a $120 handmade hat compared to a $20 factory-made one). It is very friendly to individual sellers with low entry barriers and simple operations. Fees are low ($0.2 per listing plus 5% transaction commission), making it suitable for crafters and small studios.
    • Limitations:
      • Product Restrictions: Strictly limits products to those with handmade or design elements, prohibiting mass-produced factory goods. Violations can lead to permanent account closure.
      • Smaller Traffic: Overall traffic is much lower than Amazon, although it’s highly targeted.
      • Geographical Focus: Buyers are mainly from developed countries, with weak coverage in Asia, Africa, and Latin America.
    • Suitable For: Individuals or small teams with strong design or crafting abilities. A graphic designer friend earns $3,000-5,000 in passive income monthly by selling digital download products with almost zero cost, benefiting from the “one creation, infinite sales” model.
  • eBay (E-Bei):
    • Overview: An older platform that remains one of the largest online marketplaces with ~159 million active buyers. It functions like a traditional flea market, allowing both new and used items. The core logic is to facilitate free trade between buyers and sellers, with the platform providing basic infrastructure and trust.
    • Advantages: Offers an extremely low entry barrier for small and medium sellers; individuals can sell without company licenses, only needing a payment account. It’s a good starting point for low-cost cross-border e-commerce ventures. eBay is especially suited for second-hand items, collectibles, and vintage goods, categories that may not perform well on Amazon. Competition can be less intense, particularly in niche segments. It allows for “sell first, then ship,” reducing upfront capital pressure by not requiring pre-stocked inventory.
    • Disadvantages: Has a slower growth rate compared to newer platforms like TikTok or Temu. Combined commissions and PayPal fees amount to about 13%, which is lower than Amazon but not particularly cheap. Buyer price expectations tend to be lower, limiting profit margins.
    • Suitable For: Those looking to start small-scale or sellers with unique second-hand inventory. It can serve as a valuable starting point to gain experience before expanding to other platforms.
  • Shopee (S):
    • Overview: A leading e-commerce platform focused on the Southeast Asian and Latin American markets.
    • Advantages: Its primary advantage is the growth potential in emerging markets with low e-commerce penetration, offering greater growth opportunities than mature markets like Europe or North America. Competition is relatively lower, especially in certain niches where Chinese sellers have not yet heavily entered. Shopee actively supports sellers with subsidies and promotions. Its user base is primarily young people, making it suitable for mid-to-low end products.
    • Disadvantages: Markets are highly price-sensitive due to lower purchasing power, leading to smaller profit margins. Logistics are challenging due to underdeveloped infrastructure in Southeast Asia, resulting in longer and less stable delivery times. Cross-cultural communication can also be difficult, requiring an understanding of local languages and customs.
    • Suitable For: Products that fit the purchasing power of Southeast Asian markets or sellers familiar with these regions’ cultures. It can be a good choice for products that face fierce competition in Western markets.

The Harsh Realities of Cross-Border E-commerce

Despite the varying characteristics of platforms, several overarching challenges define the modern cross-border e-commerce landscape:

  • Soaring Traffic Costs: This is an irreversible trend. Advertising costs on major platforms have drastically increased; for example, hot keywords on Amazon saw CPCs rise over 200% from $0.5-0.8 in 2018 to $1.5-3 today. This means the same marketing budget yields significantly less traffic.
  • Intensified Competition: The industry is now saturated, with Chinese sellers active on virtually all platforms and local sellers emerging. “Easy money” is gone. Success now demands core competitiveness: a unique product, strong brand advantage, superior operational capabilities, or significant capital. Without these, the chances of success are minimal.
  • Stricter Platform Rules and Higher Compliance Costs: Platforms continuously raise standards for user experience, product quality, logistics, customer service, and refund policies. Violation costs have risen sharply, with serious infringements potentially leading to permanent account bans and total loss of initial investments. For instance, Amazon’s near “unconditional refund” policies significantly increase seller operational pressure and costs. Compliance-related expenses alone can constitute around 12% of total costs.
  • Training Institutions Exaggerate Success and Hide Risks: Many training organizations inflate success rates and conceal high failure rates, perpetuating survivor bias. They promote outdated “lying-down-to-make-money” strategies. Furthermore, many trainers lack practical experience, offering outdated or compiled course content. They are in the business of “selling dreams, not teaching skills”. A seller who lost $600,000 on Amazon admitted to recouping it within a year by running training courses, by telling students “stories they want to hear” about easy success.
  • Underestimated Supply Chain Complexity: Managing a cross-border e-commerce business involves significant challenges in finding reliable suppliers, ensuring product quality, handling international logistics, and managing seasonal fluctuations. Issues in any of these areas can lead to substantial losses (e.g., a 30% return rate due to inconsistent product quality from a supplier leading to account demotion).
  • Underestimated Capital Requirements: Starting a cross-border e-commerce business with small capital is largely a “pipe dream”. A minimum of $100,000 in preparation funds is typically needed to cover product development, inventory, advertising, warehousing, and logistics until profitability. Claims by training institutions that one can start with “a few thousand dollars” are misleading. The industry has evolved from a “lying-down-to-make-money” opportunity a decade ago into an “arms race” today.

Pathways for Newcomers

For individuals new to cross-border e-commerce, a more realistic and gradual approach is recommended, abandoning “get-rich-quick” fantasies:

  • Start as a Virtual Assistant (VA): Work for existing cross-border sellers to learn practical skills, understand industry operations, and build connections. Platforms like Upwork offer remote VA jobs (e.g., listing optimization, product research, customer service) at $5-20 per hour, providing “paid learning” opportunities.
  • Provide Services to Sellers: This strategy is akin to “selling shovels in a gold rush”. It carries less risk and doesn’t require pre-stocking inventory. Examples include:
    • Platform account setup and operation services.
    • Cross-border logistics solutions.
    • Product photography and image processing.
    • Multilingual customer service outsourcing.
    • VAT registration and declaration services, especially for the complex European VAT system. (An accountant friend provides this service to over 200 clients monthly, with stable income and low risk).
    • Product description and advertising copy optimization. (A friend specializing in English writing earns over $10,000 monthly, charging $50-100 per listing).
    • The demand for such services persists as long as the industry exists, with lower initial investment and risk compared to selling goods directly.
  • “Small Niche, Then Expand” : For those determined to sell goods, start with a small niche and gradually invest in building a supply chain.
    • Enter Niche Markets: Focus on specific hobby areas (fishing, gardening, pets), products solving particular problems, niche cultural items, or regional specialties to avoid intense competition. This allows one to become a “big fish in a small pond”. (An Australian friend successfully sells local natural skincare to the Asian market, leveraging regional recognition and cost advantages).

In conclusion, cross-border e-commerce is a legitimate business that demands professionalism, accumulated experience, and significant investment. The industry is not a scam in itself, but promotional messages promising “zero investment, zero threshold, and lying down to make money” are categorically deceptive. Opportunities persist for those who are grounded, well-prepared, and patient, recognizing that success is a result of consistent effort and strategic growth.

Think of cross-border e-commerce not as a lottery ticket you pick up for instant riches, but as a vast, shifting ocean. The advertised “lying down to make money” schemes are like colorful, flimsy rafts promising a smooth sail to treasure island. In reality, the currents are strong, the waves are high, and the ocean is full of experienced sailors on sturdy ships. To succeed, you need to learn how to navigate, understand the weather patterns (platform rules), maintain your ship (supply chain), and be prepared for storms (risks and competition), or better yet, become a skilled shipbuilder or navigator providing essential services to others on the sea.